top of page

 

  

 

 

Growing up, we always had sweet potatoes stored in our can house.  That was a

 

 

small concrete building with thick walls and a roof that my dad built and it never

 

 

got ​​below 45 degrees in there.  Any root vegetables were always stored covered

 

 

by sand in homemade wood boxes and there were rows of shelves for all the

 

 

canned goods put up in the summer.  It was also a great place to step in and cool

 

 

off since there was no air conditioning in our home.

 

There are as many variations of sweet potato casseroles as there are cooks.  Some make a savory version but I like mine on the sweeter side.  I am offering two toppings, a marshmallow and a pecan, and it really depends on what I have available in my pantry as to which one I use. 

When choosing sweet potatoes for a casserole, try to get ones that are close to the same size.  They can be boiled, but I prefer to wash them, wrap in foil and bake at 350°F until they feel soft when squeezed (see recipe).  Once unwrapped, the skin is easily removed.

​​

Why I like this recipe . . .

♥  Simple, easy to find ingredients.

♥  It will quickly become a family favorite, especially on your holiday buffet.

♥  This sweet potato casserole will be devoured completely at any family function.

♥  There are 2 simple toppings.​​​​

♥  It's easily doubled.

About the ingredients:

•  Sweet Potatoes-I like to use medium size without many blemishes.

•  Sugar-White, light or dark brown sugar work equally well.  

•  Butter-Salted or unsalted, no margarine.

•  Vanilla-Use a good quality vanilla (our recipe here)

•  Milk-You can use whole or skim milk, or even orange juice. I prefer whole     milk because of the richness it gives.

•  Egg-Use large or extra-large.  The egg binds the ingredients in your               casserole.

•  Toppings-Mini marshmallows or pecans (with flour, butter, and sugar)

 

Ingredients

•  2½ cups mashed cooked sweet potatoes (about 3 medium)*

•  ½ cup granulated sugar (could also use light or dark brown sugar)

•  1 Tbsp butter, softened

•  1 tsp vanilla extract

•  ¼ cup milk (orange juice works too)

•  1 large egg

 

You will need a buttered casserole dish.

                             

Instructions

1.   Preheat oven to 350° F. Thoroughly scrub the sweet potatoes, wrap individually         in foil and bake about 1 hour or until soft when squeezed.

2.  Cool, peel and mash or chop the sweet potatoes.  Add the sugar, butter, milk,             eggs and vanilla to the sweet potato mixture.  Spoon into a small greased                  baking dish, then add one of the toppings.

Topping 1

Ingredients

•  ½ cup brown sugar, packed

•  ¼ cup all-purpose flour

•  ½ cup chopped pecans

•  2 Tbsp butter, softened     

 

Instructions

1.  Mix all the ingredients together and crumble over the sweet

    potato mixture.

2.  Bake about 30 minutes until browned and set.

Topping 2

Ingredients         

•  ½ to ¾ cup mini marshmallows 

 

Instructions

1.   Bake the casserole for about 20 minutes then sprinkle the marshmallows over           the top. 

2.  Return to oven and bake about10 more minutes until brown and puffy.  Watch           carefully to prevent burning.

*You can also use a large can (40 oz), of drained sweet potatoes.  Usually they are    sweetened, so sugar may not be necessary.

A close-up shot shows a sweet potato casserole, topped with toasted marshmallows, crunchy pecans, and sprinkled with cinnamon.
A silver spoon lifts a scoop of  sweet potato casserole, revealing a layer of creamy orange sweet potato topped with a crunchy brown crumble of pecans, butter and cinnamon.

Sweet Potato Casserole

  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram

LAURA LEE ALICE
COOKS

Don’t love itNot greatGoodGreatLove it

 

Sweet Potato Casserole

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest

Recipes are like stories; they can change from person to person.  Everyone has their idea of how a recipe should be, even

 

 

though it may have changed from the original.  We will never know the true author of the original recipe, regardless of

 

 

what some may say.  That's why I go back and look through the oldest cookbooks that I can find.  Sometimes it's not the

 

 

recipe in the books that I find, but the tiny pieces of handwritten recipes and newspaper articles that are stuck within

 

 

the pages.  That's where the real story is, finding those simple Southern recipes.      -Mac

Copyright © 2025 Laura Lee Alice, LLC. All rights reserved.

LAURA LEE ALICE COOKS

 

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you.

bottom of page